BAR ISLAND COTTAGE - Town of Milbridge

LOCATION: Milbridge, Pigeon Hill Bay - Picturesque Maine Cottage On a Car Accessible Island

  4 guests
  2 bedrooms
  1 full bathrooms
  Allows Pets
  900 sq. ft.

Instant Quote

Sleeping Arrangement

Bedroom 1
1 Queen
Bedroom 2
2 Twins

Property Info



1st Floor- Open Kitchen-Living-Dining Area, Queen Bedroom, Bathroom with stall shower and laundry

2nd Floor- Open loft bedroom with 2 twin beds.

DOGS PERMITTED? Dogs are considered at this property. All dogs must first meet our Pet Guidelines to be considered. J2

One of the more romantic cottages we offer for rent, this beautiful newer cottage on the shores of Pigeon Hill Bay is a great retreat for honeymooners or a small family looking to get away from it all. Close to the villages of Steuben, Milbridge, and the entrance to the Schoodic Point section of Acadia National Park, this property is also a wildlife lover's dream. Despite the label that this property is on an island, it is easily accessible by car over a causeway.

With views from every room, you will love preparing meals in this kitchen with stainless steel counter tops and appliances. Curl up on the couch on a cool day and warm up by the gas fireplace stove while watching birds on the bay. At low tide, clam diggers work along the shore. Be sure to introduce yourself and buy some of Maine's most delicious natural treat. Live Lobsters and Crabs may also be purchased daily from nearby Dorr Lobster Pound, also located on Bar Island.


BOATS: Boats are not included with this rental but guests may rent kayaks or SUP's for delivery and pick up to the property from Sunrise Canoe & Kayak

SECURITY DEPOSIT: No, the owner of this property does not require a security deposit, however, guests are still financially responsible for non-accidental damages at the property.

Property Specifics:
Linens & Bath Towels:
Yes, one set of bed linens and one bath towel set for each guest are included (beds are made up prior to guest arrival)
Cleaning: The property will be cleaned before and after the rental. Above normal cleaning charges will be billed to guest at the current hourly rate
Air Conditioning: No - but fans are located in each bedroom
Heat Source: Radiant Floor Heating, Propane Heating Stove
Washer & Dryer: Yes
Dishwasher: Yes
Coffee Maker: Yes, standard automatic drip with filters
Internet Access: Yes - Satellite Internet with Wi-Fi (talk to us if you aren't familiar with satellite internet service and how it works) - Service is NOT set up for streaming movies - guests should not use it for that purpose - just to check e-mail and do light browsing. The Millbridge Library does have great internet service.
TV: 1 TV with basic satellite service and DVD
Grill: Charcoal Grill - charcoal briquettes NOT supplied by owner
Usable Fireplace: No, Gas Heating Stove
Outdoor Firepit: No
Water Source : Well water (okay to drink from tap)
Trash Removal : Included with rental - put bags in shed, picked up on Saturdays
Closest Shopping Village: Milbridge - 6 Miles away
Number of Restaurants within 10 Miles: 3
Water Frontage: Yes
Beach Access: Small sandy area and rocky shore
Dock/Pier Access: No
Additional Amenities: Minimum Standards List

Exploring Area



Jun - 2023
        1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30
Jul - 2023
2 3 4 5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15
16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 27 28 29
30 31
Aug - 2023
    1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31
Sep - 2023
          1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30
Oct - 2023
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30 31
Nov - 2023
      1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30
Dec - 2023
          1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30
Jan - 2024
  1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31


Page: 2 of 3 Write a Review
Armonk, US
Reviewed: Aug 27, 2018
Property Manager
Northampton, GB
Reviewed: Aug 13, 2018
Property Manager
Wiley, US
Reviewed: Aug 6, 2018
Property Manager
Bruce was very good about contacting us and making sure everything was working at the cottage.
The view was fantastic. It was great to find the kitchen with so many extras that we do not usually get when renting vacation homes.
Ayer, US
Reviewed: Jul 23, 2018
Property Manager
Excellent - very thorough
Beautiful panoramic views and very quiet.
Apex, US
Reviewed: Jul 2, 2018
Property Manager
Easy to work with, we had no issues so did not need to contact anyone. Bruce stopped by just to make sure all was well, very nice and helpful.
We had an absolutely lovely stay. The cottage is beautifully appointed, we loved every minute of our stay. The windows are so great to just sit and gaze out.
Darlington, GB
Reviewed: Jun 25, 2018
Property Manager
Very helpful and informative , instructions and information given well in advance , easy to contact if needed .
Secluded location , complete privacy with amazing views over the bay.The cottage is light and airy ,very well equipped and well maintained .It was just as described on the web site . We went to relax and spent hours watching the tides , the sunsets and the wildlife .
Montrose, US
Reviewed: Oct 18, 2017
Property Manager
Hesperia, US
Reviewed: Sep 11, 2017
Property Manager
Charlottesville, US
Reviewed: Sep 7, 2017
Property Manager
Concord, US
Reviewed: Aug 5, 2017
Property Manager
Professional - efficient- responsive. Thanks!
This is a truly rare experience in Maine, even for those of us who have visited the coast often. The property sits alone on a point near the head of a tidal inlet, facing due west. Sunsets last a hour; breeze from the ocean is constant, and this is dark sky country - amazing! When we weren't sitting on the open porch watching the natural world go by, we were relaxing in a beautifully simple open interior with all the amenities we needed.
Lewiston, US
Reviewed: Jul 12, 2017
Property Manager
wonderful working with you. been very sweet to talk to when i called.
love this place. being on the ocean and watching the sunsets are private and quiet. we been renting for 5 years at same place would not change a thing.
Corinth, US
Reviewed: Jun 24, 2017
Property Manager
Easiest and quickest reservation and contract execution I have experienced. Everyone I have dealt with at the agency is friendly and helpful. Don't want to use any other agency because the process is so easy and the availability calendar is up to the minute current so there are no disappointments later finding out something isn't actually available.
Location on calm water area with easy access to the water from the small pebble beach during high tide. Deck and water view from all areas of the house. The privacy and quiet location. Radiant floor heating and gas fireplace heater. The layout of the house is great for a couple. Clean and comfortable. Too many favorite features to list!
Myrtle Beach, US
Reviewed: Jun 7, 2017
Property Manager
On the Water in Maine are good people to work with..We rent a house at least once a year around the country and they are easy to work with
Great House. Our 2nd time to rent this house
Crozet, US
Reviewed: Sep 25, 2016
Property Manager
In my interactions with your reps, they were friendly, responsive and clear.
The Bar Island cottage is a great location to watch the tides and to kayak in protected waters. Wonderful view from anywhere in the house. At low and mid tide, there is a narrow gravel beach (adjacent to the stone steps to right of cottage) that works to launch a kayak or retriever into the water. The Bar Island cottage is a well designed and well build cottage. It's furnishings are very functional and uncluttered, giving it a feeling of serenity that fits the location. The views of the protected bay are simply great. The kitchen is well furnished and useful. About amenities, as a rural property with satellite internet service, bandwidth has a monthly cap. If prior renters use up the 15 GB monthly allowance, internet service is super slow/ barely useful. Cell phones with hot spot capability work as alternatives. It could be a good idea to give heads up to future renters that bandwidth is likely to be limited in case they count on getting online while on vacation using the property's bandwidth.
Ashford, US
Reviewed: Aug 22, 2016
Property Manager
Always a pleasure.
We love the quiet, we love the water, we love the trees, we love the birds. We hope to return.
Lakeville, US
Reviewed: Aug 13, 2016
Property Manager
You have a very detailed process and it worked well although some of the reminders were a bit much towards the end. I would imagine it is necessary to ensure all goes smoothly and it did so I will say it was a good experience. I would use your services again.
Loved the location, quiet, secluded and right on the water. The cottage was spacious, bright, cheery, beautifully decorated and offered water views from every window. The wrap around deck provided plenty of seating space in or out of the sun. Our only "visitors" were locals, seagulls, Osprey fishing in the waters in front, 2 seal visits, crows, a beautiful bald eagle who flew right over our heads and a hummingbird who "buzzed" us daily. The location was perfect for numerous day trips and I have nightly pictures of the wonderful sunsets. Lovely!
Richfield, US
Reviewed: Jul 31, 2016
Property Manager
This was our second summer staying at the Bar Island home, and it was just as wonderful this year as it was the first. It's peaceful, beautiful, and gorgeously designed.
Middletown, US
Reviewed: Jul 17, 2016
Property Manager
On the Water in Maine were easy to work with and all went very smoothly.
Thank you for sharing the your cottage it was perfect for four of us. We had family staying on Bar Island road and spent our days with them and nights at the cottage.
Blacksburg, US
Reviewed: Jul 11, 2016
Property Manager
They answered each of my laborious questions quickly helped me with the information I needed.
We appreciated the incredible attention to detail for all the things that we would possibly need during our stay. At the same time the house was not cluttered with knick knacks, making it effortless for us to move in with our belongings. The aesthetic sensibilities of the interior of the house was also noted and admired.
Middleburg, US
Reviewed: Oct 7, 2015
Property Manager
A bit complicated, but for understandable reasons. Worked well!!
Wonderful location. Peaceful and unhurried. Highly recommended
Indianapolis, US
Reviewed: Sep 26, 2015
Property Manager
The agency was very helpful and gave us very clear directions.
The view is breathtaking! We were able to get away for a few days without our kids so we really wanted quiet and privacy and we go exactly that. Beautiful and clean property as well!
Jersey City, US
Reviewed: Sep 5, 2015
Property Manager
Working with "One the Water in Maine" was effortless. Website was very easy to work through and the staff was very helpful and friendly when speaking with them on the phone. The reservation, contract, and payment was seamless. The electronic combination lock at the property made things very easy.
Absolutely love the privacy of the Bar Island Cottage. The cottage had everything we could want regarding kitchen items. Bathroom was perfectly sufficient, although a hair dryer would have been nice. Had great fun watching the tide roll in and out. The views of the water and of the night sky were outstanding! Cottage was quintessential Maine! The minute we arrived, we knew we were at the right spot, and talked about coming back.
Indianapolis, US
Reviewed: Aug 29, 2015
Property Manager
Maynard, US
Reviewed: Aug 18, 2015
Property Manager
On the Water was fabulous, easy, helpful and patient with all my questions. We totally want to rent from you again!!!!!!
We absolutely loved how clean it felt. The couches were a little low and the small spoons were really small - can you tell I'm digging for problems? We just loved the place. Even the bed was super comfy!
Verdun, CA
Reviewed: Aug 2, 2015
Property Manager
Easy to deal with, extremely communicative and straight forward. I would not hesitate to seek out On Water in Maine again when looking for a vacation property rental.
It was a pleasure to stay at the Bar Island cottage. It was clean, cozy, well supplied and easy to get to. Incredibly close to the water with its' ever-changing scenery due to tidal currents and abundant wildlife surrounding the property.


Smoking Is Not Permitted anywhere on or inside of any of our rental properties nor are those who may partake in tobacco smoking allowed to occupy any of our properties.

Occupancy may not exceed what is posted for each home. Maximum occupancy could include infants and children.

Amenities offered through On the Water in Maine Inc. are not available at all the properties we offer for rent. Boat Rentals through Maine Watercraft Rentals Inc. are offered Sunday morning to Friday after 4pm and include free delivery to the property. Check with an agent to find out what boats are available to rent at this property, or, when you process the booking here online, only the boats available for the property will be listed as available to rent.

Please see our Rental Guidelines Page for further questions regarding how to book this property and additional charges and fees. Contact a reservation agent for more details or to ensure you are booking the right property for you.

Town Info - Milbridge, Harrington & Down East

Milbridge, Harrington & Down East
The first rays of dawn illuminate the West Quoddy Lighthouse each morning before reaching any other point in the U.S. Located in Lubec, its the easternmost lighthouse in the country. Visit Maines DownEast & Acadia Region, to see just how beautiful it is!
Learn More