Guest Reviews
Write a ReviewKathryn
Raleigh, US
Reviewed: Sep 10, 2026
Property Manager
Your staff did a wonderful job assisting us in finding the perfect property to fit all of our preferences within our budget. Every interaction with your team has been handled with efficiency, enthusiasm and a cheerful and positive attitude. Yours is the best rental agency we have ever used anywhere!
Property
Our stay at Loon Call was extremely comfortable and relaxing. The house was very clean and nicely decorated. The kitchen had all the equipment we needed for cooking, including a new gas range and dishwasher. Our favorite feature was Seven Tree Pondlooking at it, paddling the kayaks on it, and sitting by it at the fire pit to enjoy the starlight and Loon Calls.
View Property: Loon Call
Christine
Schenectady, US
Reviewed: Sep 8, 2026
Property Manager
Always a pleasure. Very easy to get info check in and check out.
Property
Loved the location and the view. Kitchen cabinet space limited, to put any foodstuffs away, but well appointed.
View Property: Owls Head Guest Suite
Sally
North Oxford, US
Reviewed: Sep 7, 2026
Property Manager
The team is the best! Very well run agency.
Property
We love Safe Harbor. The new owners have made many upgrades and this year we were happy to see air conditioning units added to the bedrooms. We rented a pontoon boat that was a hit with the kids.(and me!)
View Property: Safe Harbor on Megunticook Lake
Adam
New York, US
Reviewed: Sep 6, 2026
Property Manager
Fairly easy process. Team was responsive to my questions.
Property
Beautiful home. Our favorite feature was probably the large outdoor deck.
View Property: Lermond Overlook
Terry
Tampa, US
Reviewed: Sep 6, 2026
Property Manager
Always great to work with the team.
Property
We love the cabin
View Property: Redwood Cabin
John
Skillman, US
Reviewed: Sep 5, 2026
Property Manager
Very easy to work with. Thanks!
Property
This is probably our 10th stay at Castlewood. Its a great cottage, perfectly located for all the sites we love to visit in Maine
View Property: Castlewood Cottage
Robert K.
New York, US
Reviewed: Sep 3, 2026
Property Manager
As always, the On The Water In Maine team has been wonderfully helpful, patient and friendly. You're the best!
Property
We have stayed at Deep Cove for over a decade of annual visits. It's the perfect vacation home for us in all ways, from the property's great siting to the home's design and comfort.
View Property: Deep Cove Cottages
Janet
Madison, US
Reviewed: Sep 3, 2026
Property Manager
Great experience. Friendly, easy to work with, and easy process.
Property
We loved this property. It was perfect for our family. We enjoyed the comfortable surroundings, and the location on the pond. Favorite feature was the deck/living room area overlooking the pond - we could watch the grandchildren playing, the fisherman in our family fishing, the activities from the public landing, and seeing the wildlife (loons, heron, ducks, eagles, beavers!)
View Property: Camp Peabody
Roy
Columbia, US
Reviewed: Sep 1, 2026
Property
View Property: Bar Island Cottage
Susan
Charlottesville, US
Reviewed: Sep 1, 2026
Property Manager
As always, terrific!
Property
We love Bellevue Cottage and the wonderful view!
View Property: Bellevue Cottage
Catherine
Beaufort, US
Reviewed: Aug 31, 2026
Property Manager
Your team is very organized and thorough. The information in the book answered any questions that we had. Check in and out is easy.
Property
Our favorite feature is the view. The cottage is just what you would imagine a Maine cottage should look like!
View Property: Seafarer Cottage
Richard
Orlando, US
Reviewed: Aug 31, 2026
Property Manager
Perfect as always except for the unreturned call about the television. I called on the morning of the 15th and was told someone would get back to me later that day. No one did.
Property
We've stayed at Waterside upwards of a dozen times. It never disappoints. It's nothing fancy, but everything meets our needs. And the access to downtown and to the waterfront is a huge plus.
View Property: Waterside Retreat
Dave
Middletown, US
Reviewed: Aug 31, 2026
Property Manager
Smooth and easy process
Property
Clean, modern and wonderful views
View Property: Eco Vista
Edward
Hartford, US
Reviewed: Aug 31, 2026
Property Manager
Very easy to work with!
Property
We continue to love our stays at the Norton Pond Cottage. Great location, beautiful gardens, love the expanded dock!
View Property: Norton Pond Cottage
Will
Brooklyn, US
Reviewed: Aug 31, 2026
Property Manager
always great communication and helpful
Property
best property weve stayed in thus far, loved the pool, the bay views, the giant master bedroom, the chef's kitchen.
View Property: Penobscot View
JoAnne
Bristol, US
Reviewed: Aug 30, 2026
Loretta
Chevy Chase, US
Reviewed: Aug 30, 2026
Property Manager
Very easy
Prompt responses to inquiries
Property
Jones Cottage on Juniper Rd in W Boothbay
The water views were the best feature.
View Property: Jones Cottage
Kelly
Danville, US
Reviewed: Aug 30, 2026
Robert
Odenton, US
Reviewed: Aug 30, 2026
Property Manager
OTW has been outstanding for the last 5 years!!
Property
Periwinkle Cottage has been our home away from home for 5 years but we think its time for a change. It has become expensive as the owners have increased its rent $8,000 during that time.
View Property: Periwinkle Cottage
Heidi
Natick, US
Reviewed: Aug 30, 2026
Property Manager
They were very professional and quick to respond.
Property
We love woodland cottage. It fits our family perfectly. We love the screened in porch and the yard.
View Property: Woodland Lodge
Irene
Falls Church, US
Reviewed: Aug 29, 2026
Property Manager
After two years of experience with you, we think you do a great job: your information is clear and helpful; you are only a phone call away when something (small or not) is needed; and everyone we worked with has been informative, polite and very helpful.
Property
Golden Owl was truly great: the space, the accommodations, the provisions and supplies, the good taste in color and furniture choices, the lovely outdoor settingto name a few of the good features. The kitchen was a breeze to adjust to, and the layout was immediately comfortable. One guest said, You know this is just really nice.
View Property: Golden Owl
Lynn
Bardstown, US
Reviewed: Aug 29, 2026
Property Manager
The rental process is always easy, and I REALLY appreciate you being able to break up my payment since it's so large and I rent so far ahead of time.
Property
Same comments as last year, lol.
Stephanie includes SO many amenties at Our Song. I won't rent anyplace that doesn't include kayaks for getting out on the water as well as any place that doesn't have air conditioning.
I love that you can enjoy unobstructed views of the lake while being in the main room and master bedroom of the house. The kids utilized the paddleboards and ping pong table the most.
View Property: Our Song
Robert
Chestertown, US
Reviewed: Aug 27, 2026
Property Manager
Spectacular! Very client responsive.
Property
The location was the selling point for us more than anything about the property. Property is very nice, if a bit oddly configured, but also very "fancy." Felt more like a New York apartment than a Maine cottage.
View Property: Harbor Hideaway
Michael
Washington, US
Reviewed: Aug 26, 2026
Property Manager
We've always found them responsive and helpful - thank you!
Property
This was our second summer at Blue Cottage and it's a lovely place. When we came in the house was, once again, so immaculate it looked brand-new. We rented a kayak and I enjoyed paddling around Lake Norton. Our favorite feature is the porch overlooking the lake and the dock itself, which we enjoyed sitting on in the evenings. We enjoyed watching a few shows on the world's biggest TV upstairs.
View Property: Blue Cottage on Norton Pond
Lori
Chagrin Falls, US
Reviewed: Aug 25, 2026
Property Manager
Everything was very easy and efficient with the on the water team
Property
Our favorite feature was loft in the house and the fact that the family allowed dogs. It meant a lot to us to be able to share vacation time with them
View Property: Kenneys Port of Call